The work to implement that in both emscripten and SpiderMonkey has recently completed, and here are the performance numbers:
Run times are normalized to clang, so lower is better. The red bars (firefox-f32) represent Firefox running on emscripten-generated code using float32. As the graph shows, Firefox with float32 optimizations can run all those benchmarks at around 1.5x slower than native, or better. That’s a big improvement from earlier this year, when as mentioned before things were closer to 2x slower than native. You can also see the specific improvement thanks to float32 optimizations by comparing to the orange bar (firefox) next to it – in floating-point heavy benchmarks like skinning, linpack and box2d, the speedup is very noticeable.
Another thing to note about those numbers is that not just one native compiler is shown, but two, both clang and gcc. In a few benchmarks, the difference between clang and gcc is significant, showing that while we often talk about “times slower than native speed”, “native speed” is a somewhat loose term, since there are differences between native compilers.
In fact, on some benchmarks, like box2d, fasta and copy, asm.js is as close or closer to clang than clang is to gcc. There is even one case where asm.js beats clang by a slight amount, on box2d (gcc also beats clang on that benchmark, by a larger amount, so probably clang’s backend codegen just happens to be a little unlucky there).
Overall, what this shows is that “native speed” is not a single number, but a range. It looks like asm.js on Firefox is very close to that range – that is, while it’s on average slower than clang and gcc, the amount it is slower by is not far off from how much native compilers differ amongst themselves.
There are some ways to work around that issue, such as the outlining option which reduces maximum function size. We have some other ideas on ways to improve code generation in emscripten as well, so we’ll be experimenting with those for a while as well as following when Math.fround gets supported in browsers (so far Firefox and Safari do). Hopefully in the not so far future we can enable float32 optimizations by default in emscripten.
View full post on Mozilla Hacks – the Web developer blog